Orthomolecular medicine

Not all magnesium is the same: which form is the right one?

Pharmacies and chemists stock dozens of magnesium products: oxide, citrate, glycinate, malate, threonate and many more, each with its own promise. Which form is absorbed best, which do you tolerate well, and what really matters? We summarise what studies show.

The essentials in brief

  • Organically bound forms such as citrate, and also chloride, dissolve better and in most studies are absorbed somewhat better than magnesium oxide. The differences are often small.
  • In healthy people, all common forms replenish the body’s stores. Whether this also applies to people who are ill and to older people has been studied less well.
  • What matters is the amount of pure magnesium, spreading it over several small doses, and how well you tolerate it.
  • For newer forms such as threonate, taurate, malate or orotate, there are no reliable advantages in humans.
  • If your kidney function is impaired, take magnesium only after consulting a doctor.

What we need magnesium for

An adult’s body contains about 25 grams of magnesium. A good half of it is in the bones, the rest almost entirely in muscles and other cells. Magnesium is involved in more than 600 enzymes, in energy production, in nerves and muscles and in the heart rhythm. The daily requirement for adults is taken to be about 350 milligrams for men and 300 milligrams for women.

A deficiency arises above all with diarrhoea and bowel disease, with diabetes, with regular alcohol consumption, in older age and through medication: diuretics and stomach acid blockers (proton pump inhibitors) taken over a long period. Early signs are tiredness, weakness and loss of appetite, later tingling, muscle cramps and heart rhythm disorders.

Why the blood value is often misleading

Less than one per cent of the body’s magnesium is in the blood serum, and the body keeps this value constant for a long time, if necessary at the expense of the bones. A normal serum value therefore does not rule out a deficiency. Measurements in whole blood, in red blood cells or in urine add to the picture, but there is no single, accurate test for the total stores. The assessment, together with the symptoms and the causes, therefore belongs in a doctor’s hands.

The forms compared

In supplements, magnesium never comes on its own but always as a salt, bound to a partner. The partner determines how well the salt dissolves, how much pure magnesium it contains and how well the gut tolerates it.

FORMMAGNESIUM CONTENTABSORPTION IN HUMANSTOLERABILITY
Oxide61 %Poorly soluble and poorly absorbed in capsules; considerably better as an effervescent tabletLaxative in larger amounts, also used as a laxative
Carbonate29 %*Hardly studied in humansDiarrhoea common
Citrate16 %Readily soluble, in studies usually better than oxideCan stimulate the bowel
Bisglycinate (glycinate)14 %*Hardly any direct comparisons; in one small study the same as oxideWell tolerated
Chloride12 %In one study as good as lactate and aspartate, better than oxideDiarrhoea possible
Lactate12 %Better than oxideUsually well tolerated
Aspartate10 %Better than oxideUsually well tolerated
Sulphate (Epsom salt)10 %Absorbed less wellStrongly laxative, hence used as a laxative
Malate, taurate, threonate, orotate7 to 16 %*No studies on absorption in humansHardly any data

Magnesium content: the share of pure magnesium in the salt. Values marked * are calculated from the chemical formula, without water of crystallisation.

Inorganic forms: oxide, carbonate, chloride, sulphate

Magnesium oxide contains the most magnesium per gram and is inexpensive. However, it hardly dissolves in water and only partly in the acidic stomach. In one study, only 4 per cent was absorbed from oxide, considerably more from chloride, lactate and aspartate. What is not absorbed binds water in the gut: this is why oxide and sulphate have a laxative effect and are used specifically for constipation. Chloride is also inorganic, but it dissolves well and in the same study was absorbed as well as the organic forms. Dividing them into “organic good, inorganic bad” is therefore too simple.

Organic forms: citrate, lactate, aspartate, glycinate

Magnesium citrate is the best-studied organic form. It dissolves well even in water. In a double-blind study over 60 days, magnesium levels rose more with citrate and with a form bound to amino acids than with oxide, which did not differ from placebo. In another study, by contrast, the difference between citrate and oxide was so small that it hardly matters to the body. Bisglycinate (glycinate), magnesium bound to the amino acid glycine, is considered particularly well tolerated. However, there are hardly any comparative studies on its absorption.

Special forms: threonate, taurate, malate, orotate

These forms are often advertised with special effects: threonate for the brain, taurate for the heart, malate for energy. The evidence for this comes mainly from animal experiments. In humans, there are a few small, short studies on threonate, often supported by the manufacturer and with contradictory results. For taurate and malate, studies on absorption in humans are lacking altogether; for orotate, there is a single study in severe heart failure. In addition, these salts contain little magnesium, so you need more capsules for the same amount.

How reliable is the evidence?

Most comparative studies are small, older and designed differently, and some were funded by manufacturers. Two reviews reach the same conclusion: organic forms tend to be absorbed somewhat better, but which form is best cannot be said with certainty. A study of 15 products also showed large differences between individual products, even of the same form. So the preparation matters too, for example whether a tablet dissolves well.

Whether a particular form works better for a particular complaint has hardly been studied. The only larger study that compared three forms over half a year (citrate, oxide, sulphate) found no difference in the blood value and no effect on blood pressure with any form.

What magnesium has been shown to help with, and what not

  • Migraine: probably effective for prevention, especially with 600 milligrams of citrate daily. This amount is above the limit for food supplements and should be taken under medical supervision.
  • Calf cramps: in older people, a Cochrane review shows no noticeable benefit. In pregnancy, the picture is unclear.
  • Blood pressure: on average a small reduction of about 2 mmHg, not in all studies.
  • Sleep: in older people, a few small studies with a weak effect.

Frequently asked questions

What should I look for on the packet?

The amount of pure magnesium, not the amount of the salt. 500 milligrams of magnesium citrate contain only about 80 milligrams of magnesium, 500 milligrams of magnesium oxide about 300 milligrams.

How much is too much?

The European Food Safety Authority considers 250 milligrams per day in addition to food to be safe. Above that, diarrhoea becomes more common. From food alone you will not take in too much magnesium as long as your kidneys are healthy.

When and how should I take it?

Ideally with meals and spread over two or more doses. The larger the single dose, the smaller the share the gut absorbs. Whether in the morning or the evening makes no difference according to current knowledge.

What about other medication?

Magnesium can reduce the absorption of some medicines. Keep at least two hours apart from osteoporosis medicines (bisphosphonates). Take certain antibiotics (tetracyclines, quinolones) at least two hours before or four to six hours after the magnesium. Anyone taking diuretics or stomach acid blockers should have their magnesium requirement checked by a doctor.

Who should be careful?

People with impaired kidney function. The kidneys excrete excess magnesium. If they do not work well, it can accumulate and lead to a drop in blood pressure, muscle weakness and heart rhythm disorders.

Our conclusion

There is no single right form. Readily soluble forms such as citrate or chloride and the well-tolerated glycinate are a sensible choice; oxide is more suitable if the bowel also needs a nudge. More important than the form are the right amount, good tolerability and the question of why there is a deficiency in the first place. We look for this cause together with you in the orthomolecular assessment.

Sources

  • German Nutrition Society (DGE): Ausgewählte Fragen und Antworten zu Magnesium (selected questions and answers on magnesium). January 2022.
  • EFSA Panel on Dietetic Products, Nutrition and Allergies: Scientific Opinion on Dietary Reference Values for magnesium. EFSA Journal, 2015.
  • National Institutes of Health, Office of Dietary Supplements: Magnesium. Fact Sheet for Health Professionals. Updated 2022.
  • Schuchardt J. P., Hahn A.: Intestinal Absorption and Factors Influencing Bioavailability of Magnesium: An Update. Current Nutrition & Food Science, 2017.
  • Pardo M. R. et al.: Bioavailability of magnesium food supplements: A systematic review. Nutrition, 2021.
  • Arnaud M. J.: Update on the assessment of magnesium status. British Journal of Nutrition, 2008.
  • Costello R. B. et al.: Perspective: The Case for an Evidence-Based Reference Interval for Serum Magnesium. Advances in Nutrition, 2016.
  • Fine K. D. et al.: Intestinal absorption of magnesium from food and supplements. Journal of Clinical Investigation, 1991.
  • Lindberg J. S. et al.: Magnesium bioavailability from magnesium citrate and magnesium oxide. Journal of the American College of Nutrition, 1990.
  • Firoz M., Graber M.: Bioavailability of US commercial magnesium preparations. Magnesium Research, 2001.
  • Walker A. F. et al.: Mg citrate found more bioavailable than other Mg preparations in a randomised, double-blind study. Magnesium Research, 2003.
  • Kappeler D. et al.: Higher bioavailability of magnesium citrate as compared to magnesium oxide shown by evaluation of urinary excretion and serum levels after single-dose administration in a randomized cross-over study. BMC Nutrition, 2017.
  • Schuette S. A. et al.: Bioavailability of magnesium diglycinate vs magnesium oxide in patients with ileal resection. Journal of Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition, 1994.
  • Blancquaert L., Vervaet C., Derave W.: Predicting and Testing Bioavailability of Magnesium Supplements. Nutrients, 2019.
  • Schutten J. C. et al.: Effects of Magnesium Citrate, Magnesium Oxide, and Magnesium Sulfate Supplementation on Arterial Stiffness. Journal of the American Heart Association, 2022.
  • Guerrera M. P., Volpe S. L., Mao J. J.: Therapeutic Uses of Magnesium. American Family Physician, 2009.
  • Srinutta T. et al.: Proton pump inhibitors and hypomagnesemia: A meta-analysis of observational studies. Medicine, 2019.
  • Morishita D. et al.: Senna Versus Magnesium Oxide for the Treatment of Chronic Constipation: A Randomized, Placebo-Controlled Trial. American Journal of Gastroenterology, 2021.
  • Slutsky I. et al.: Enhancement of learning and memory by elevating brain magnesium. Neuron, 2010.
  • Liu G. et al.: Efficacy and Safety of MMFS-01, a Synapse Density Enhancer, for Treating Cognitive Impairment in Older Adults. Journal of Alzheimer’s Disease, 2016.
  • Ni Y. et al.: Magnesium L-threonate for chemotherapy-induced cognitive impairment, pain and sleep in breast cancer. Breast Cancer: Targets and Therapy, 2023.
  • Uysal N. et al.: Timeline (Bioavailability) of Magnesium Compounds in Hours: Which Magnesium Compound Works Best? Biological Trace Element Research, 2019.
  • Stepura O. B., Martynow A. I.: Magnesium orotate in severe congestive heart failure (MACH). International Journal of Cardiology, 2009.
  • Holland S. et al.: Evidence-based guideline update: NSAIDs and other complementary treatments for episodic migraine prevention in adults. Neurology, 2012.
  • Peikert A., Wilimzig C., Köhne-Volland R.: Prophylaxis of migraine with oral magnesium: results from a prospective, multi-center, placebo-controlled and double-blind randomized study. Cephalalgia, 1996.
  • Garrison S. R. et al.: Magnesium for skeletal muscle cramps. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2020.
  • Zhang X. et al.: Effects of Magnesium Supplementation on Blood Pressure: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Double-Blind Placebo-Controlled Trials. Hypertension, 2016.
  • Mah J., Pitre T.: Oral magnesium supplementation for insomnia in older adults: a Systematic Review & Meta-Analysis. BMC Complementary Medicine and Therapies, 2021.

Orthomolecular medicine